The Sunken Synagogue
pa vezer o vageal e kreiz e klever a-wechoù un trouz iskis:
kleier ur sinagogenn a zo o seniñ dindan ar mor...

Thursday, October 12, 2006
 
One of these things is not like the other....

Whereas some news sources, as well as some blogs, try to make their headlines catchy and enticing, Arutz 7 often uses its headlines to make a point.

Take this one: Synagogue Planned For Temple Mount, Hashemites to Add Minaret.

This casual juxtaposition is a valiant attempt at equating two spectacularly different ideas. Everyone knows that one of these two plans will come to fruition, while the other will not. One will hardly cause a stir, while the other would spark riots. One is put forward by a unified front, while the other is a subject of serious internal dispute. But they shouldn't be so different, A7 is telling us, and we have to strive to make the former as acceptable as the latter.

MK Ariel, the man behind the synagogue proposal, probably knows he's pissing in the wind, but he's trying to make a statement too, and sometimes one has to be willing to engage futility for a while in order to raise awareness. I can't say I support him here though, because even so much as walking onto the temple mount is far from universally sanctioned halachically, let alone building a synagogue there. He can talk about consult leading torah scholars on every step of the process, but this line is also a rhetorical trick, because by pursuing the idea at all, he's already ignoring the large segment of rabbis who oppose it.


Technorati tags: / / / /

 
Comments: Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link



<< Home

מי הוא זה ואי זה הוא

Name: Sabzi Aash
Location: Jerusalem, Israel

View my complete profile


ראה זה חדש

The Three Little Yids: An Instructive Sukkos Fairy...

The Three Little Yids: An Instructive Sukkos Fairy...

Insane in the Mediterraine*

The Aliyah Blues* **

Beneath the Planet of the Iranians

Dressing Iran up and down

Olmert? We don't want any....

The blog must go on ... but not really

You could be a minister too

Top Israeli celebrity trap nabs another victim


בין הבלוגים

AbbaGav
The Aliyah Blog
Ari's Blog
Aspaqlaria
Balashon
Ben Bayit
Ben Chorin
Beyond BT
Biur Chametz
Chardal
Cosmic X
Cross-Currents
Daled Amos
End of Days
Galileeblog
The Hall of the Goblin King
The Hashmonean
Hirhurim
If you will it...
Israelity
Israellycool
Israel Perspectives
Israel, Zionism, politics, and aliya
IsraPundit
Jewish Nation

JoeSettler
The Kosher Blog
Lazer Beams
Life In Israel
Mar Gavriel
The Muqata
Mystical Paths
On the Main Line
PaleoJudaica
Parshablog
Perspectives of a Nomad
Point of Pinchas
Postcards from Israel
Rebel Jew
SimplyJews
Yeranen Yaakov
Yiddishe-Kop 2.0


מימי קדם

March 2006
April 2006
May 2006
June 2006
September 2006
October 2006
November 2006
January 2007
February 2007


Powered by Blogger