The Sunken Synagogue
pa vezer o vageal e kreiz e klever a-wechoù un trouz iskis:
kleier ur sinagogenn a zo o seniñ dindan ar mor...

Monday, January 08, 2007
If you didn't like Yonatan Bassi before...

I've been shaken from my blog-neglecting stupor by an amazing story from YNet.

Yonatan Bassi, who was the head of the Disengagement Authority that coordinated the complete removal of thousands Jews from the Gaza Strip a little over a year ago, has decided to move off of his kibbutz, Sde Eliyahu, for a couple of years. He and his family have been experiencing harrassment from a vocal minority of fellow kibbutzniks who haven't gotten over what he did while in that post.

Many will surely see this as divine punishment, מידה כנגד מידה. He expelled others, and so he has to leave his own home. Fine ... though it doesn't seem to be be exactly measure for measure, since he's only going temporarily, he's not being hoisted out by soldiers, he doesn't have to watch his home being bulldozed and the ruins given to Arabs, and he's not going to be lied to and mistreated by the government. But anyway, he's getting some of the medicine he doled out ... close enough.

We can all look at this and smile and smirk at this pitiful man. But it doesn't really move me. I mean, it's predictable. Of course he was going to get his, later on if not now. What's positively shocking though is what he and his wife wrote in a letter to the director of their kibbutz:

"We love this place, and we love those living in it. We were both born here. The sunrise above the Gilad mountains every morning has accompanied us since the dawn of our childhood. Our entire adult lives have been invested in Sde Eliyahu. And now, on the brink of old age, how can we move to another place?" they wrote.
"A year and a half ago, we bounced back from a difficult period," wrote the Bassis. "It is very difficult. It is difficult for the people of Israel, difficult for Sde Eliyahu, and difficult for us, too. This period has created a crisis in the our relationships with some of our friends...."

That's chutzpah! How can they whine about experiencing the same thing they afflicted others with? Bassi kicked people out of the homes they loved and grew up in, with no respect for age or sentimentality, or the social and economic crises that would result. Does he think the former residents of Gush Katif don't get misty-eyed over their old homes and neighborhoods, the sun and the sand and surf, the gardens? Does he think they — not "the people of Israel," not he and his kibbutz up in the the Galilee, but the people in Gaza he smacked around — haven't been through a difficult period, that the parents among them aren't now going through divorces and the children turning to drugs?

I'm at a loss. This is worse than chutzpah. This is cruel, blind insensitivity. Stupidity. Callousness. He sets the next house on fire and then complains when the flames come back at him? People from Gush Katif are expendable and their well-being can be sacrificed, but if the blade grazes his fingertip all of the sudden there's a problem?

It's too bad, Yonatan Bassi! Eat it! Be thankful you're not moving to a caravilla!


I spoke too soon.

Anonymous informs me in the comments that Bassi is in fact moving to a caravilla. I don't know if this has been reported in English, but here's the story in Hebrew. It's also claimed there that although the Bassis only requested a two-year leave of absence, they're not likely to return.

Spooky, eh? If it didn't look like middah k'neged middah before, it sure does now. What I'd like to know is: what is Yonatan Bassi thinking now? I suspect that even if he hasn't yet a mind for repentence over his role in the Disengagement, he must have one heck of a grimace on his face.

Thanks, Anonymous.

Technorati tags: /

Yonatan didnt "kick people out of their houses " - this was done by the State , his job was to help the residents of Gush Katif . Unfortunatly the leaders of the Gush were stuck in their messianic "haloh lo tihiyeh" and hindered all help .Do you think he did all this for money ? he got much more working for the private sector . Did he do it out of hate ? he helped the gush when he worked in the ministry of agriculture . He did it because he believed 1 - it was good for Israel , 2 - he , as a dati jew , could best help . You may think he is wrong - but to hate him is a mistake
Thanks for the comment. I'm trying, but I can't see him as helping the people of Gush Katif in anything but the most superficial sense. It's a role I could better attribute to people and charities who came in after the deed was done.

Am I saying that one has to wait until after the fall to offer a helping hand? Not at all. But if the destructive action is still preventable, to offer aid or accept it is to prematurely accept it as a fait accompli, which weakens the resistance and strengthens the offense. Furthermore, if people are confident that the victims will be taken care of, it helps the destructive party to feel better about itself and placates many who would otherwise oppose it. Do you think as much of the public would have accepted the expulsion if there hadn't been any government efforts at compensation? Of course, if Basi hadn't done it, someone else would have, but that's never been an acceptable excuse. So if he did not push anyone out with his own two hands, I count him as a willing accomplice at best.

As for the expulsion actually being good for anyone ... if you or Yonatan Bassi thinks that running away from enemies who are still running towards you puts you in a stronger position ... I don't really know what to say to you. I think most of the Israeli public wasn't thinking at all, couldn't accept any other ideas, and wanted an easy, PC "solution" that wouldn't harm anyone but a few thousand crazy settlers off in the borderlands, and would make them feel like a concrete step is finally being taken ... in some direction. But it's my opinion, anyway, that the expulsion was deadly wrong, and Yonatan Bassi played an integral part in it.
When are used to sacrificing our own people at the feet of the enemy, hoping to make them go away by appeasing them.The more you give, the more they want.
By the way, what kind of sabzi is that? the one for Ghorme Sabzi?
The kind for soup.
I hadn't notice the Aash part!
I was wondering!
I wonder if you were tongue in cheek saying

"Yonatan Bassi! ...Be thankful you're not moving to a caravilla!"

Because, that is exactly what he is moving in to:
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
This is interesting!! What anonymous says is more interesting.

Keep posting!!

This is Nancy from Israeli Uncensored News
Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home

מי הוא זה ואי זה הוא

Name: Sabzi Aash
Location: Jerusalem, Israel

View my complete profile

ראה זה חדש

Who Really Won the Holocaust Cartoon Contest?

Jesus Christ Superstar and Israel's Existential Cr...

Rav Ovadia Yosef Opines on the Presidency

American, British, and Israeli Cultures In a Nutsh...

There are some things money can't buy. For everyth...

Double, double, toil and trouble

Much Ado In Iran

Sderot Gets Desperate

The Sukkot Aftermath

One of these things is not like the other....

בין הבלוגים

The Aliyah Blog
Ari's Blog
Ben Bayit
Ben Chorin
Beyond BT
Biur Chametz
Cosmic X
Daled Amos
End of Days
The Hall of the Goblin King
The Hashmonean
If you will it...
Israel Perspectives
Israel, Zionism, politics, and aliya
Jewish Nation

The Kosher Blog
Lazer Beams
Life In Israel
Mar Gavriel
The Muqata
Mystical Paths
On the Main Line
Perspectives of a Nomad
Point of Pinchas
Postcards from Israel
Rebel Jew
Yeranen Yaakov
Yiddishe-Kop 2.0

מימי קדם

March 2006
April 2006
May 2006
June 2006
September 2006
October 2006
November 2006
January 2007
February 2007

Powered by Blogger